Saturday, July 3, 2010

Book Thirty-five: Five Quarters of the Orange

Book Thirty-five: Five Quarters of the Orange
Finished: June 21, 2010
Pages: 336

I have read one of Joanne Harris’s other books, Chocolat. That book is certainly similar in a number of ways to Five Quarters. Both set in France, with strange names for many of her characters, and food. Food always plays a huge role in her books. Little wonder that she has put out a couple of cookbooks.
Set during the German occupation of France, this story deals with the lives of three French children, their mother, and their interactions with a German soldier. The children (Boise is nine at the time, the eldest, Cassis is not even sixteen) spy on their neighbors in order to gain favor with Tomas: “We were wild animals, just as Mother said, and we took some taming. He must have known that from the start, the clever way he set out to take us one by one, making each feel special…Even now, God help me, I can almost believe it. Even now” (108). Over the course of the book, the relationships between all the various characters come to light as Boise, now an old woman, discovers her mother's recipe book and all the secrets it contains.

Woke at six this morning, for the first time in months. Strange, how everything looks different. When you haven’t slept it’s as if the world is sliding away bit by bit. The ground isn’t quite in line with your feet. The air seems full of shiny stinging particles. I feel I’ve left a part of myself behind, but I can’t remember what. They look at me with such solemn eyes. I think they’re afraid of me. All but Boise. She’s not afraid of anything. I want to warn her that it doesn’t last forever.


Many of the issues the characters face are ones that are of their own making. Although you would think that I would place the blame on the Germans, and the secrecy that didn't allow for free expression which led to the tragedy in the book, but I don't. I place the blame on the shoulders of all the characters, especially Boise. She causes a lot of the trouble in the book through her own choices to be trouble herself. Although in the end she regrets some of these actions, “Of course, by then there were to be no more oranges, ever again. I think even I had lost my taste for them” (222), I felt that she was not as remorseful as much as avoiding blame and consequences.

Good Reading,
Caitlin

Tuesday, June 8, 2010

Book Thirty-four: The Disappeared

Book Thirty-four: The Disappeared
Finished: June 8
Pages: 235

How do you write about unspeakable things? How do you put into words the loss and despair faced by the survivors, by those who lived through these atrocities, who have families who go through them? How do you say these things, so that people will stop talking and listen?How do you put the loss of thousands upon thoughts of people into words?

This is the struggle faced by people who want to write about the Holocaust, the Rwandan genocide, or the killings in Cambodia under Polpot. How do you write about something so violent, so horrible that it defies all speaking of it? Because in a way to put it in words is to acknowledge that human beings are capable of such violence. To put it in words limits the horror to the words on the page, and I don’t think that any words can truly encapsulate the systematic murders of any number of people, much less thousands upon thousands of people. Kim Echlin attempts to put the horror into words in the book The Disappeared.

She attempts to humanize the victims, to give faces to those who are now nothing but dust. She also attempts to give voice to the horror of the survivors, those who truly survived, and the walking dead to survived but not completely. For, as horrible as it is for those who are dead; the true pain is felt by those who keep living. “The tortured stay tortured. After the bodies were cleared, imagine what people had to do. Imagine the stench that clings” (103). Her unique blend of the far past, the recent past, and the present, jumping back and forth in the narrative, disorients the reader while also allowing the reader to feel the whirlwind romance of our narrator, Anne, as she meets, loves, loses, finds, and loses Serey, a Cambodian student and musician who is trapped in Canada after the closing of the Cambodian borders. When the borders re-open, Serey leaves without the much younger Anne to search for his family. Ten years later, Anne follows his face, haunted by images on the television. Some aspects of this book I think were really well done. I like the impact of the occasional super-short chapter. Some of her prose is excellent, calling up emotions and images that perfectly capture a moment or feeling. For example, when talking about her childhood, being brought up by a single father, on page 11 she says:
When he read to me he sometimes looked at the black and white picture of my mother on my bedside table. The focus is soft on the young woman holding a baby, me, and our eyes are locked together. Papa’s voice would drift away and I learned to wait quietly until his attention flickered from the photograph back to the page. I think I began to read this way, studying the words in an open book, waiting for absence to be filled.

The only thing that really annoyed me was the narrator herself. Maybe I’m just not romantic enough to really think that if I had fallen in love at 16 with a man considerable older than me that ten years after he left me I would travel more than halfway around the world to track him down with no address, much less that I would learn a completely new language, brave a war-torn country that was dangerous to travel in, much less without any plan or contact. Sometimes the sap is just so overwhelming that it feels too romantic for a novel about genocide. “I saw the world more sharply with you, as if I had put on new lenses, the left a little stronger than the right, but worn together they shaped blurred edges into clear lines, There were moments I would have liked not to see so sharply. Borng samlanh,[my dearest darling] I wanted to know everything about you. I was young and but slenderly knew myself” (43). Or for example, the entirety of Chapter 45: “I can still see a particle of dust hanging in a sunbeam near your cheek as your slept” (135).

Overall, I think that considering the subject matter, Echlin did a superb job. I certainly couldn’t put the book down. Many parts of the book will stick with me, much like I can still remember many parts of the movie Hotel Rwanda for the same reason, they are too haunting to forget.

“Long ago, when they emptied Phnom Penh, closed the borders, people remembered things, the last time they slept in a bed, the last time they saw a loved one. There was that last telegram out of Phnom Penh before all lines to the outside world were cut: I ALONE IN POST OFFICE. LOSING CONTACT WITH OTHERS. I AM TREMBLING. HOW QUIET THE STREETS. NOWHERE TO HIDE. MAY BE LAST CABLE TODAY AND FOREVER” (170).

Good reading,
Caitlin

Thursday, June 3, 2010

Books Thirty through Thirty-three: The Pagan Chronicles

Book Thirty: Pagan's Crusade
Finished: June 1
Pages: 256

Book Thirty-one: Pagan in Exile
Finished: June 2
Pages: 336

Book Thirty-two: Pagan's Vows
FInished: June 3
Pages: 336

Book Thirty-three: Pagan's Scribe
Finished: June 3
Pages: 368

Okay, as you might remember (or as you read below) I read Babylonne without realizing that it was a sequel to this series, so I decided to read the rest of them to see if I liked it better afterward. The answer is certainly "yes." There is something endearing about Pagan, the young Christian Arab who grows up in Jerusalem during the medieval Crusades, and the fall of Jerusalem to Salahadin. Pagan becomes a squire to a young Templar knight named Roland, and the first three books are told from Pagan's point of view as they adventure from Jerusalem to the south of France. My favorite book, however, is Pagan's Scribe, the fourth, partially because it introduces a new character, Isidore, who I had met previously in Babylonne. The endearing quirks of Pagan's character, the amusing sarcasm that is his irreverant nature, and contrasting deep love for his friends is much more apparent from an outsider's perspective. While I think that perhaps a teenager might enjoy these books more than I did, I certainly didn't hate them at all. They were funny, and the witty banter that Pagan keeps up, first with himself, then with Roland, and finally with Isidore, would be enough to keep me reading.
"Name?"
"Pagan Kidrouk, sir."
"Age?"
"Sixteen. Sir"
"Born in?"
"Bethlehem."
Rockhead looks up. The brain peeps out from behind the brawn.
"Don't worry, sir. It didn't happen in a stable."
Clunk. Another jest falls flat on the ground.

"Why did you leave?"
"It was the jokes, sir. In the guardroom. Not that I object to jokes as such. Some of my best friends are complete jokes. But I don't like leper jokes. Or dysentery jokes. Especially when I'm eating."

The grammar issues that I faced with Jinks' other writing is even more apparent here. The incomplete sentences, as well as multiple tangential phrases did at times make it difficult to keep up. During battle scenes in the first book, and then in other times of fast action, it is hard to keep track of who is talking, but often seemed purposeful, since in the heat of the moment it would be difficult to keep track of what was going on in real life.
I think that the characters were well developed, and certainly Babylonne would have made so much more sense had I read these in order, but at the same time, I had a good time figuring out the mystery that was Pagan in the same way that Babylonne herself did, through a whole lot of digging. I wouldn't recommend this book to a really high-minded Christian, since there is quite a bit of blasphemy, but anyone with a decent brain between their ears would see that most of the irreverence is directed towards stupid characters rather than God. All in all, pretty hilarious, and I'm glad I wasted my days reading them.

Good Reading,
Caitlin

Monday, May 31, 2010

Book Twenty-nine: Babylonne

Book Twenty-nine: Babylonne
Finished: May 31
Pages: 384

Okay, I'll be honest. I picked this up on a whim, when I was looking for the second book in the Mortal Instruments trilogy at the library. Since they didn't have the book that I was looking for, I decided to go with a random book that had intrigued me for a while. Since it's my last week in the library at school for three months, I've been picking up a lot of these books since they are fast reads and generally entertaining. Besides, if they aren't entertaining, I don't feel bad about just taking them right back downstairs.
So, I didn't realize that this book was part of a series when I first picked it up. It certainly stands on its own, but I will say this, it probably would make more sense if I had read the others first. The story is of a young girl named Babylonne who lives during the 1200's in France, and her travels of discovery, both of herself and her absent parents. My hope is that if I had read some of the other books I would have a better understanding of the culture and characters. Babylonne is a member of a sect of Christianity called Cathars, and knowing nothing about either that faith, or the politics of the time, I was lost for a vast majority of the book. The style of writing also takes some getting used to, as most of the book is written in a stream of consciousness style that interrupts itself interrupting itself. Very hard transition to make from the more straightforward narrative I had been reading the past few books. To be sure, Babylonne's voice is very apparent, and she does seem to come alive once you get past the first few chapters and get into the swing of things. She has an entertaining and sarcastic view of the world that certainly does not fail to amuse. For example, when describing her grandmother's snore she says "She has a snore like an armored corpse being dragged across dry cobblestones" (11). I mean, can you really be more descriptive?
I have many questions about her father, Pagan, who apparently is the main character in all the previous books. I think that these questions would be answered already had I noticed that there was a particular order to them. Whoops. Perhaps I will hold off all further judgment of the narrative and its plot holes until I have read the other books. After accustoming myself to the style of prose, I had a good enough time, but we shall see. I certainly enjoyed it enough to read the rest of the series.

Good Reading,
Caitlin

Book Twenty-eight: Catching Fire

Book Twenty-eight: Catching Fire
Finished: May 28
Pages: 391

Okay, so I might have been less than truthful about The Hunger Games in my last post. It might seem that I was a bit ambivalent about my enjoyment of the book. I checked out the sequel before I left work on Friday, went home, and finished Catching Fire before I went to bed Friday night. I couldn't put it down. I had to know what was going to happen with the main characters, Katniss, Peela, and Gale, not to mention their families. I wanted to know what would happen to the games themselves, and where the author was going with this world and the people in it. This book certainly delivered. This second chapter fleshes out the consequences to the actions taken in the first book. I like that the book doesn't pull its punches. When violence is called for, violence happens. You can love characters and then watch them hurt and maybe even die. If your government is willing to hurt the public, then the public does get hurt. The author gives brilliant descriptions of costumes, scenery, and technology that really help the reader to get a foothold in a world that is both familiar and unfamiliar at the same time. Having a sequel allows the author to flesh out the details that had been left fuzzy: the government, the other districts, and everything else that wasn't really explained well in the first one.
I'm not going to lie to you, these books are a real thrilling read, and I hope that more people will go read them, if only to be able to recommend them to their students, or their children. They are better written than Percy Jackson, but obviously the world is much less developed than either that world or Harry Potter. While I still wouldn't highly recommend this book to those who don't like science fiction, they're totally worth it if you do like science fiction.

Good Reading,
Caitlin

Friday, May 28, 2010

Book Twenty-seven: The Hunger Games

Book Twenty-six: The Hunger Games
Finished: May 28
Pages: 374

The Hunger Games
is one of those books that so many people have talked about that I wasn't really sure whether I even wanted to read it or not. Books have a hard time living up to the expectations that others give. But, since it's the end of the school year, and one of the alternative end-of-year assignments was a book study over the book, I thought "what the heck" and checked it out of the library yesterday afternoon. I finished it in about 5 hours, if that is any indication of the quality of the narrative. It's not the best young adult novel out there, but the idea is interesting, and well written.
Here is the basic plot: America has been destroyed and rebuilt into 12 districts and a capital. The Capital keeps control over the districts by having the Hunger Games each year, where a boy and a girl from each of the twelve districts engage in a fight to the death on live television, and there can be only one winner. Sixteen year old Katniss Everdeen takes her twelve year old sister's place in the Hunger games, and then must prove to herself and the world whether she can survive.
The idea of The Hunger Games in general reminds me of a few other things, this Japanese book that I can't remember the name of, and "The Lottery." It was a good read, and I definitely recommend it to anyone who likes dystopian novels.
Good Reading,
Caitlin

Thursday, May 27, 2010

Book Twenty-six: City of Bones

Book Twenty-six: City of Bones
Finished: May 27
Pages: 485

Okay, so I've seen these books on the shelves at the library and the bookstores for a few years now. Many of my students have recommended them to me, but I've never gotten around the actually reading one of them until now. To be perfectly honest, I was concerned that it would turn into another Twilight fiasco. I just don't see that much in the way of decent fantasy written these days, much less written for young adults. It tends to be either horrible trite or overly juvenile. I was pleasantly surprised by this book. I am not going to tell you that it is the greatest thing since sliced bread or anything, but definitely not as bad as the covers would perhaps make you suspect.
Although the premise (teenage girl discovers that she is "different" is drawn into a world where nothing is as it seems/discovers her secret past/powers/family she's never known) is as old as fantasy itself, the writing is interesting and humorous when it needs to be, and the description is vivid and appealing. If you like fantasy you wouldn't completely waste your time this summer reading it by the pool, but don't feel like you'd be really missing out if you read something else instead.

Good Reading,
Caitlin